ALAN ALEC CASS CASSIE CASSY_MOBILE CORA DJ DONNA DONOVAN DREW DUNCAN GAIL JO KATE MALONE MANAGER MASKED_MAN MASKED_MAN_1 MCCABE MEG MOLLY PEREZ RHONA SALLY SANDY THOMAS TOSH PEREZ Hey, Rhona, any news? RHONA Well if you've got plans for the weekend, cancel them. Malone just won his appeal. RHONA The Advocate General wants to reopen the Kilmuir case. PEREZ Okay. GAIL It's over Thomas, it's over. GAIL So, come on, what do you want to do first? A pint? THOMAS No I, I just want to go home. PEREZ Thomas Malone, convicted in 1994 for the murder of Lizzie Kilmuir. PEREZ Was released this morning after he was acquitted by the High Court in Edinburgh. PEREZ For all of you who don't know, Lizzie Kilmuir she was strangled and her body was found inside a cairn on Unst. Thomas Malone confessed to the murder and was sentenced to life. But the CCRC have presented new evidence that was over-looked at the time of the original trial. Secondary DNA from the crime scene always pointed to a second suspect but it wasn't tested at the time. So the insinuation from the review commission is pretty clear. They think that this evidence was withheld deliberately. RHONA I doubt it. I've known Drew McColl, who was the SIO, a long time. Not his style. PEREZ Well, whatever happened, the charges were dismissed. PEREZ It's a mistrial and it doesn't paint the force in a particularly good light. MCCABE I just got word Malone landed at Sandborough about fifteen minutes ago. PEREZ I want everybody to drop what ever it is they're working on. PEREZ The Lizzie Kilmuir case it the priority. I want to see if we can get some closure for the family. Billy look out all the files that we've got on the Lizzie Kilmuir case. Tosh, get in touch with the CCRC, because we're gonna need to see everything that they've got, with evidential, non evidential, new statements, whatever. TOSH Sure. PEREZ And when we get those new statements I want everybody on 'em. Because there is a second suspect out there, somewhere. PEREZ Sandy, can I have word? PEREZ You knew Lizzie Kilmuir, right? SANDY I was at school with her. I'm still friends with her twin sister, Kate. It's not a problem. PEREZ I didn't say it was. ALAN Sally, you alright? SALLY I'm fine Alan. ALAN Yeah okay, I'm just asking. SALLY Well you asked me three times in the car. Just leave it. ALAN You got the tickets then Jo? SALLY For god sake Alan, you've got the attention span of a midgie. You need to look at her. ALAN Sorry Jo. Tickets? JO No worries, I got them. ALAN How much do I owe you? ALAN Oh thank you SALLY Here, open that will you? ALAN Starting early then? SALLY Uhuh ALAN Okay. DREW Sure you don't want one? PEREZ No no I'm fine. Really I just wanted to touch base about the Kilmuir case. DREW No problem Jimmy, just doing your job. PEREZ So this unknown DNA. Comes from a hair on a scarf, found round Lizzie's neck, and thought to be the murder weapon. DREW So why didn't I test it back then? That's your next question isn't it? PEREZ Yeah. DREW Well, I didn't think it'd yield enough DNA. PEREZ And you had your man, so why complicate matters? DREW Err no, not quite. We risked destroying potential evidence. It wasn't worth it. Best wait 'til techniques advanced enough to get a proper profile. The defence was informed of its existence. They over-looked it. I did explain that to the CCRC. SANDY Kate! Kate! KATE Hello. SANDY Hi Molly, you enjoying the bands? MOLLY It's not exactly Glastonbury is it? SANDY Well least it's not raining. Can I have a word in private? KATE We heard on the radio that Malone was released. SANDY Kate, I'm sorry. KATE You have nothing to be sorry about. SANDY We're reopening the case. As you're Lizzie's only family left we'll be in touch. I just wanted you to hear it from me. KATE Ok How have you been anyway? I've not seen much of you since you and Jenny split? SANDY I'm fine. Missing the kids I must admit. But it was for the best. KATE Can I get you a drink? SANDY Aye, I can have one. KATE Aye. Do you want a coke? MOLLY Vodka KATE No lass. A coke. SALLY Right I'm done, need another one, are you coming? ALAN Err, Aye alright. Do you want a drink? PEREZ Why did you go after Malone in the first place? DREW He cried like a baby at Lizzie's funeral. It was odd. He was odd. So I asked about. Turned out he was fixated on her. Then a witness came forward putting him on the Unst ferry the day Lizzie went missing. So we searched his house. Found chickweed on his shoes. Edmondson's Mouse Ear. It only grows on Unst. We had him. It was done and dusted. He confessed. PEREZ Later recanted. DREW Aye, well. People do. One lie after another. DREW It was a strong case. All the court has done is put his conviction in doubt, nobody said he was innocent. He did it Jimmy. I swear on my wife's grave. MCCABE Here's the search videos, crime scene photos, witness statements. MCCABE And that's only one box. There's dozens of 'em down there. Stacks of unused material. PEREZ So what was Drew McColl like to work with? MCCABE Ah he's a good man. He took early retirement when his wife died. Just him and Sally now. DREW Interview with Thomas Malone commencing Nine fifteen pm conducted by D.I. McColl and D.S. Donovan. DREW Okay, Thomas. This is your last chance. You need to stop lying. You need to tell the truth for the sake of the Kilmuir family. You understand? DREW We have a witness who saw you Thomas. On the ferry. Benny Ray. Or is Benny lying? DREW Is everybody a liar except you? MALONE No No DREW I heard she's a bit of a cock tease. DREW Did she take the mickey out of you? Is that what happened? I wouldn't blame you for getting angry. Nobody would. DONOVAN If you admit it Thomas, it'll mean a shorter sentence. DREW He's right Thomas, trust me, you keep saying you didn't do it and they'll throw away the key. Are you listening son you're going to die in prison! DREW And your mother, think about her, what will this do to her? She's not in the best of health is she? A long drawn out court case will be the end of her. MALONE No. No. No. No. No. DREW For the record Mr. Malone is shaking his head and crying. Interview paused Ten forty five pm. DREW Interview resumed Eleven Twenty Three pm. Now Thomas, let's get this straight. Did you kill Lizzie Kilmuir? Did you kill Lizzie Kilmuir? THOMAS Yeah, I did. I did DREW You did? You did what? THOMAS I killed Lizzie Kilmuir. DREW And how did you do that? THOMAS I strangled her. DREW Why? THOMAS Why because, because she went out with other people, but not me. PEREZ You still doing here? You can go. I'm not expecting you to do an all nighter. TOSH I'm good, thanks. PEREZ I thought you'd been at the festival? TOSH The thrill of trying to pee while hovering over a chemical toilet doesn't hold the same allure as it once did. PEREZ Sure. Any word of your transfer? Seems t'be dragging on a wee bit? TOSH I, I got an offer about a placement in Edinburgh. I haven't decided what to do yet. PEREZ You do know that I don't want you to go, right. If it was up to me, I'd have you tagged, so you couldn't leave. PEREZ If you ever want to talk I’m here. GAIL Hi, this is Gail Callahan, Life after appeal. Just leave your message and I'll get back to you. Thanks a lot bye. THOMAS Come on… Gail. Gail. It's me. I, I, I need to speak to you. I. I should never have come back here. I can't, I can't, I just can't do this I can’t. Gail JO Hi Drew. DREW Hi Jo. Is Sally there? I'm supposed to have breakfast with her and I can't get her on her mobile. JO Err, I don't know, I'll just go and check. JO She's not here Drew. Maybe she stayed at Alan's DREW I tried him already. SANDY We have a problem. Drew McColl called in. His daughter seems to be missing. SANDY Flat mate says she didn't come home from the festival last night, she didn't turn up for work at the Chronicle, and her boyfriend says she didn't stay with him. PEREZ Check A&E and see if she's had an accident. Hopefully she'll be fine. But treat her as a 'vulnerable person' and see if you can track her phone. SANDY Okay. TOSH Can't really see this place going a bomb on AIR B&B, can you? PEREZ You should probably know that we're gonna reopened the Lizzie Kilmuir case. So I was wondering if you'd be happy to talk to us about it? THOMAS Aye, well last time I did that, it didn't work too well for me. TOSH Don't you want to find the man who killed Lizzie? THOMAS You know, I walked out that prison yesterday with nothing. And the best part of my life was gone. If I'd been guilty I would have got a liberation grant of err, seventy eight quid. That works out about three quid a, a year. But I was innocent, so no support, no benefits, no fuck all. But aye I do, I do want to find the man that killed Lizzie. I just don't think you do. PEREZ If we find this other suspect, it can only help you. THOMAS Really! How's that? Huh? I mean look at me. Look at me. How are you gonna help me? PEREZ If anybody gives you any bother at all. You give me a call. That’s my mobile number. GAIL What are you doing here? PEREZ I'm Detective Inspector Perez, GAIL I worked that out. What do you want? PEREZ Are you a relative? GAIL Gail Callahan. I work for 'Life After Appeal'. We help people like Thomas to adjust to life outside prison. Which is more than you lot do. PEREZ I know what you do, you have nothing to worry about. GAIL You do know his blood pressure's sky high, he's got a heart condition. PEREZ It's just a courtesy call. GAIL No apology though eh. GAIL We're claiming compensation for a malicious conviction, just so you know. TOSH You wouldn't want to go on the wrong side of her, would you? PEREZ I think we already did. PEREZ Billy? MCCABE I just got a report of a body been found out at Fladdabister. MCCABE Inside an old lime kiln. PEREZ Get Sandy and forensics up there soon as. We're on our way. PEREZ Do you know Sally? Would you recognise her? TOSH Yeah. PEREZ Christ! TOSH She was at the folk festival last night and her cars still in the car park. Checked the mini-cab company and they don't have a booking in her name. PEREZ Then how did she get up here? SANDY There's no sign of her phone. PEREZ How did you get on Cora? CORA She's been there about ten to twelve hours. My first stab at cause of death is strangulation. Bruising to the head and lack of defensive wounds suggest she may have been knocked unconscious first. I can't say more Jimmy until we do the autopsy. PEREZ Okay. CORA I remember giving that girl her measles jab. Tough as old boots she was. SANDY Malone was at the festival. I saw him. PEREZ Oh don't jump the gun Sandy. There were lots of people at the festival. Go and speak to the flat mates and get what you can. I'll go and break the news to Drew McColl. THOMAS Gail I, I don't, I don't think this is a good idea. I mean what, what am I supposed to say. GAIL If you want to be accepted Thomas, people need to hear your side of it and it will help your compensation case. Trust me. GAIL Just be yourself. DJ And now we have an unusual segment to the show. Thomas Malone is with us. Many of you will know Mr. Malone has been freed from prison after serving twenty three years. Well he has agreed to come here today and tell us a bit about Life After Appeal, the organisation helping people in his situation. Now then Thomas, how does it feel to be a free man? THOMAS Err I'm. I'm not used to it yet. It takes time I suppose. DJ And I'm sure it does, now a lot has changed. Now when you went to prison Bill Clinton was President DJ And a pint of milk was 49p. How are you coping with all this new technology? THOMAS Err I'm not and the big thing for me, is the fact that my mother isn't around. She passed away when I was in prison. DJ That must have been difficult. THOMAS I was refused permission to go to her funeral. THOMAS If I'd admitted my guilt, I may have gotten out before she died. But you claim you're innocent, you might as well forget it. You'll never get parole. DJ And why was that? THOMAS They think you're in denial. DJ Oh that must err DJ Eat away at you, surely? And err, even now, this idea that you got off on a technicality. THOMAS No, not, not really. The police buried evidence, evidence that might have made the jury think twice. DJ Sure, but err, I mean in some people's minds there's still, there's still this suspicion that you really might have done it. I mean how do you deal with that? THOMAS I didn't do it. DJ Well would you say you're the DJ Same young man who went to jail twenty three years ago? THOMAS No, no, prison changes you. THOMAS I know how low people will sink. THOMAS And how cruel and heartless they can be. THOMAS You have to be like that to survive. DJ Well err, that is a DJ Pretty bleak view of the world, but suppose it's understandable in your circumstances. Now it appears we have a caller on the line. A Kate Kilmuir. Now that name'll be familiar to anyone who has read about this case, but to those who haven't err, I believe she is the twin sister of your alleged victim. Is that right? THOMAS Aye. DJ Well err, let's err, hear what she has to say. DJ Kate, you're live on air. Hello DJ What would you like to say to Thomas Malone? DJ Hello Kate? Are you still there? KATE Yes. DJ What would like to say to Thomas Malone? KATE Just one thing. KATE I'm sorry. DJ Oh what I'm sorry? DJ Is that what you said? KATE Thomas Malone is as much a victim of this crime as my sister was. KATE And I am sorry that his life was taken away from him. DJ Right well, yes that is interesting Erm, Kate DJ Is there anything else you would like to say to Thomas? Kate, are you still there? DJ Well err thank you Thomas err, for being so honest err, it's been fascinating. DREW Where did you find her? PEREZ Fladdabister. Inside a lime kiln. DREW How did she die? PEREZ We don't need to go into that right now. Really we don't. DREW How did she die Jimmy, just tell me. PEREZ We're still waiting for the pathologists report. But it looks like she was strangled. DREW Bastard! PEREZ We don't know who did this. DREW That sick twisted bastard! We both know it was him. This is revenge pure and fucking simple! PEREZ He's the first person we're gonna be looking at, you can be sure of that. DREW Just go and get him. Go and get the bastard! MOLLY Why did you say that? MOLLY You said you feel sorry for him? He killed Aunt Lizzie? KATE Now we never knew that was true. The police there not right all the time. MOLLY Have you always thought that? KATE Didn't know what to think. It's complicated. You didn't know him when he was younger. He was quiet and he was kind to us. MOLLY I can't believe you! Nobody believes him! Nobody! SANDY She won't hear you, she's deaf. I've sent her a text. TOSH You've been here before? SANDY A few times. Prowlers apparently. TOSH D.S. MacIntosh. Can we have a word? JO I just can't believe she's gone, that someone would do this to her? TOSH If you don't mind, can you tell us what you remember about last night? JO I didn't want her driving. I took her keys off her. She was gonna get a cab later. TOSH And you? JO Alan and I got a cab home together. I dropped him in town. He wanted to get something to eat. TOSH How long have you two been sharing this place? JO Not that long. She just moved in. TOSH Did you notice anything out of the ordinary happen at the festival? JO Not really. They had an argument about Sally getting pissed. But that was all. SANDY Alan and Sally? JO That's right. Then I saw her talking to this young guy. I didn't get a good look at him. He had his hood up. I'm pretty sure they weren't speaking English. TOSH What were they speaking? JO Norwegian I think. Sally speaks a bit. She covers all the Norwegian stories for the paper. SANDY We'll need her keys, to search her car. JO They're hanging by the front door. TOSH Did something happen to you? It's just that I noticed all the locks. JO I was in an abusive relationship. That's why I came up here. To get away from him. PEREZ You were at the music festival, is that right? THOMAS I never planned to go, I just went for a walk and found myself there. PEREZ So you didn't go looking for anybody in particular then? THOMAS I don't, I don't know Sally McColl. PEREZ Thomas, the daughter of the policeman who put you in prison as been found dead. If you want me to help you, you're gonna have to start telling me the truth. THOMAS I couldn't even tell you what the girl looks like. GAIL He's telling the truth. He was on the phone to me most of last night. I don't think you should answer any more questions without a lawyer present Thomas. You cannot trust these people. PEREZ Oh he can trust me, if he's telling the truth. See if your not, you're gonna wish you'd never set eyes on me. TOSH Boot's been jemmied. TOSH You got anything? SANDY No signs of a struggle. Nothing except a used boarding pass for a flight to Bergen. It's dated last week. TOSH Get forensics out here, I'll check the Chronicle. SANDY Sure. DUNCAN The only girl I know that has 'Dad's' on group text. PEREZ Any idea what's going on? DUNCAN No. You don't think she might be pregnant do you? PEREZ Well I do now. TOSH Is there anything you know that might TOSH Shed some light on what happened? ALEC No, not really, no. Sally worked twenty four seven. She was a real grafter, you know. She saw herself as a campaigning journalist. TOSH Has she had any contact with Thomas Malone? ALEC Not that I'm aware of, no. She was working on an article on her dad's career. To coincide with Malone's appeal. She probably just wanted to put his side of the story. Oh and she did our Norway View column, as well. TOSH Først Energy? ALEC Aye. Some angle she had on an accident in one of the Norwegian fields. TOSH Erm Who is A H? ALEC I don’t know, may be her source. TOSH Erm, can I have a look at her laptop? ALEC She always took that home. PEREZ Do you wanna tell me what happened? CASSIE He met someone else. CASSIE Are you really going to ignore that? PEREZ I can't. Not for long. We found a body out at Fladdabister. CASSIE Don't worry, just drop me off. PEREZ Okay. But tonight right. We can dinner and then we can talk. TOSH We can't find her laptop, it wasn't in the croft or her car, and we know she took it home every night. PEREZ And this place? TOSH Billy checked all the hotels for A H. No luck. But one name jumped out. Jan Hansen. It's the Norwegian equivalent of John Smith, could be fake. PEREZ So who do you think this A.H. Is? TOSH Sally's boss thinks it might have been someone she was investigating. PEREZ Anything strike you about this guy Hansen? Anything different. MANAGER Only that he paid in cash. Which is rare these days. PEREZ Do you think you'd recognise him, if you see him again? MANAGER I doubt it, not even sure what age he'd be. PEREZ Ticket stub, for the festival. Can we see your CCTV, please? PEREZ See if the Chemical Enhancement Lab can get some prints off that ticket stub, will you? PEREZ Jo Harley says that she saw you and Sally having an argument? ALAN I thought she was drinking too much, and she was pissed off with me. PEREZ She also mentioned that she saw Sally talking to some Norwegian, do you have any idea who that might have been? ALAN Not really. PEREZ So not a mutual friend then? ALAN To be honest with you, she had been acting pretty secretive recently. Deleting texts on her phone. You think the worst don't you. When someone's holding back. I thought that she'd met someone in Bergen. So I did the smart thing, accused her. She just looked at me disgusted that I'd even asked. PEREZ So did you not believe her? ALAN I didn't know what to believe. I thought I was losing her. DONNA It's a terrible waste. She was so bright. She wasn't scared to poke fires. I don't think she would have stayed on Shetland much longer. ALAN She never mentioned any about leaving? DONNA I just mean that she was talented and ambitious. PEREZ Do you remember seeing Sally with anybody else at the festival? Thomas Malone for instance? ALAN No. I left. I left her. DONNA He got back here about eleven. PEREZ Okay PEREZ The boyfriend suspected that Sally was having an affair. Possibly with this Norwegian. SANDY What about Malone? Did he see him? PEREZ Why would Malone jeopardise his freedom in that way? SANDY Why did he confess to killing Lizzie then change his mind? Why does he do anything? PEREZ Okay. Sally's mobile phone and laptop are missing, that may have something to do with this article what she was writing. Check if there was a Jan Hansen on any flights in and out. SANDY Are we saying this guy is our main suspect? PEREZ No. I didn't say that. SANDY 'Cos he wouldn't have been the only Norwegian at the festival? PEREZ No, but he would have been the only one trying to make himself invisible. So get a list of all the Norwegian nationals living here and run a check on the number on the post it that Tosh found. DREW I want to know why Malone isn't in one of your fuckin' cells right now? DREW He thinks he's untouchable. He knows you're too scared to arrest him again. He did it then, and he's done it again. He's laughing at us Jimmy!! He's laughing at all of us! RHONA Come on. Come on. Come with me, we'll go and find somewhere quiet to talk. CASSY MOBILE Hi this is Cassy Perez, please leave a message. PEREZ Hey Cass, probably not gonna be home till late. But if your still up, we could talk then. PEREZ I, I love you. I'll see you later. Bye. TOSH Is Cassie Okay? PEREZ No I don't think so. What have you got? TOSH The number on the post-it From the chronicle was a mobile registered to an Andreas Hagan. It a Health and Safety Officer at Først Energy. PEREZ Were they in the news recently? TOSH Yeah. There was an accident on one of their rigs. A Shetland man was killed. And there's been claims of negligence on the part of the company. If that's what Sally was working on it would explain why she was being so shifty. PEREZ Okay. Go and talk to the dead man's family and see if Sally has been in touch. PEREZ How's Drew? RHONA I don't know how he'll ever get over this. I really don't. RHONA And he's got a point y'know. We are on dangerous ground with Malone at liberty. PEREZ The only reason that we are looking at him for Sally is because of Lizzie, and I'm not convinced he killed Lizzie. RHONA There's pretty damning evidence against Malone and, and he confessed, remember. PEREZ Maybe I don't buy the confession. PEREZ He denied it, there was a break, then he admitted it. I would just like to know what happened between those two interviews to make him change his mind. Because something did. MEG Danny was a roughneck in the Norwegian Sector. Dovra Field. Before he was killed he told me that the company were cutting corners, safety regulations being ignored. TOSH In what way exactly? MEG Equipment not being maintained properly. We were told he was working on the drilling deck when his arm got snagged in the drive shaft. MEG They spin eight hundred times a minute. It tore his arm clean off. He bled to death. MEG And since the moment it happened, Først Energy have been trying to blame Danny so they don't have to pay out. They said he'd been drinking. They've got blood tests and everything. But it's a bare-faced lie. TOSH And you spoke to Sally McColl about this? MEG I told her I knew for a fact there wasn't a guard on that drive shaft. Danny told me he'd complained about it loads of times. TOSH What about the name Andreas Hagan? Does that mean anything to you? MEG Mean anything? Hagan wrote the report. He's the one saying that Danny was drunk. CASSIE What's all this? DUNCAN Tag Team Dad's. Jimmy said he'd given you a dizzy so I'm filling in. You have to eat! CASSIE And quickly it would appear. DUNCAN This boy of yours, you do know he's got no taste. Don't yer. CASSIE You haven't seen his new girlfriend. DUNCAN Well then, he's very shallow and he does not deserve you. DUNCAN Come on tuck in. CASSIE I will in a bit. DUNCAN Okay. They smile at each other, their relationship is in a good place now. DUNCAN This could be a blessing in disguise. You know. All this, I mean you could go back to university. CASSIE I want to hang round here for a bit. I'm thinking of doing something voluntary. Working with a charity maybe. DUNCAN That's a good idea. Apart from the fact you don't get paid. CASSIE Yeah but I just need to do something fun. Something that'll give me a bit of faith in people again. MOLLY Is six alright? Mum? KATE Huhum! MOLLY Look KATE It’s okay. THOMAS Thank you, for what you said. On the radio. KATE No need. THOMAS You know. You know I always believed that you thought it was me. KATE I never said that. THOMAS I thought the world of Lizzie, y'know. KATE I know you did. I remember. THOMAS I wish that none of this had happened to you. KATE Thank you. THOMAS Your wee girl, eh? Looks just like you and Lizzie did. KATE You okay? MOLLY What was he? KATE He just wanted to say hello. That was all. It's alright. Okay? It's alright. PEREZ I think she's been drowning her sorrows. DUNCAN Aye. She'll bounce back. PEREZ Might take more than a bottle of wine and a pizza though. DUNCAN I'm more worried that she doesn't want to go back to uni. PEREZ Let's give her a wee bit of time. You must remember what it was like? No, you've got no idea what it was like. You've never been chucked. DUNCAN No. I was always the chucker, never the chuckee. She needs to get in, into the big bad world Jimmy. Once she settles in here, she'll never leave. PEREZ What's wrong with that? DUNCAN What you want her wasting her talents? PEREZ No, but if she does nee want to go, I'm not gonna force her. PEREZ I want her to be happy, where-ever she is. DUNCAN I, so do I. I want he to fulfil her potential y'know. PEREZ Aye PEREZ Cass, you're better off in your bed darling. CASS What time is it? PEREZ It's late. Did you, get any of that to eat? CASS I wasn't hungry. PEREZ Darling, I can make you something now if you like? CASS The fridge is empty. What have you been living on anyway? I'm surprised you don't have scurvy. CASS It's like someone died. CASS Sorry, that was stupid. PEREZ That's exactly what it's like. Like nothings ever gonna be the same again. Yer man had his chance and he blew it. CASSIE I just can't get used to the fact I'll never see his face again. PEREZ 'Now my ladder's gone, I must lie down where all ladders start, in the foul rag and bone shop of the heart'. PEREZ It's the only poem I remember from school. It'll get better. I promise. CORA She was strangled using a scarf. Or possibly a soft belt. No skin under her finger nails and no foreign DNA on her or her. PEREZ There any defensive wounds? CORA No. PEREZ So she either knew her attacker or they surprised her. CORA Or she'd passed out. PEREZ How similar is this to the Lizzie Kilmuir case. Can you remember? CORA It could be coincidence the body was found in a Lime Kiln, or a copycat, or maybe even someone deliberately wanting you to believe it was Thomas Malone. Perez, he's already thought about all that. CORA One thing that is similar, is the victims. Lizzie and Sally were alike, both strong willed, and very bright. But you already knew that. MCCABE Can I have a word? I was checking the paperwork on Tosh's transfer and it appears she withdrew the request weeks ago. She's not going anywhere. ALAN Mum thought I'd find you here. She wants you to come to our house for some food. DREW I don't feel like eating son. ALAN Me too. But that won't help. DREW Malone! ALAN Drew! Wait! DREW Malone! ALAN Drew, what are you doing? Leave him. DREW i'm talking to you! why did you have t'come back here? ALAN Don't get into a fight with him please! DREW You just wanted to punish us didn't you! Didn't you? Well enjoy your freedom Malone, enjoy the sun on your face, live every minute like it will be your last, because you are going back inside! THOMAS Your daughter she didnee deserve this. But you did. DREW Bastard! KATE Stop it! Stop it! Get off him. Get off! Just stop it the pair of you. Thomas. It's alright, okay? It’s ok. It's Alright. KATE They just followed Thomas down the road, and attacked him. PEREZ Who hit him first? KATE The younger man. He just started shouting and punching him. KATE I imagine what happened to Sally as thrown everyone. PEREZ I was listening to you on the radio. PEREZ D'you mind me asking what made you phone in, in the first place. KATE I didn't like the tone of the interview. PEREZ Now is that because you always thought that Thomas was innocent? KATE I had my doubts. PEREZ Well then, do you mind me asking why didn't you say that at the time? KATE Nobody asked. PEREZ You were never interviewed by the police? KATE No, they said they didn't want to put me under any unnecessary pressure if they didn't need to. PEREZ Because you're one of the very, very few people on this Island that doesn't think Thomas killed your sister. KATE There are very few people on the Island who actually knew my sister. SANDY So how d'you wanna play this? TOSH If we don't charge Alan Killick with common assault, it'll be open season on Malone. SANDY He was provoked. TOSH Got about a dozen witnesses saying he wasn't. PEREZ Give him a conditional caution. If it happens again it counts as a charge. SANDY And what about Drew McColl? PEREZ C'mon drew, I'm gonna give you lift home. DREW Do you still miss Fran? PEREZ I still have bad days, every now and then. DREW My Eileen killed herself. You probably heard that. Sally always blamed me. She never said it. But, it was there. Felt I, didn't threat her depression seriously. Now I've lost 'em both. Never take your daughter for granted Jimmy. Don't let her slip away. SANDY Molly was checking the town centre CCTV from the night Sally went missing. SANDY There he is getting a take-away at midnight. PEREZ Alan Killick. SANDY According to Donna, he was home by eleven. Then this. SANDY Either he decided he wasn't hungry or he was deliberately trying to give himself an alibi. PEREZ Alright check the Taj. See if they remember. See if he went anywhere else. PEREZ Any news on that ticket stub? TOSH First attempt failed to get a usable print, they said they'd have another go, but it's not looking good. Also, I checked Gail Callahan's phone records. The call between her and Thomas Malone on the night Sally went missing lasted no more than three minutes. So she's either telling porkies or she's 'misremembered'. PEREZ Right, don't stay too late. Night. TOSH I've withdrawn my transfer request. TOSH I just, I don't feel ready yet. PEREZ Okay. TOSH I didn't want to tell you. I thought you'd think I was a bit pathetic. PEREZ I think whatever decision you made. Either to stay or go, was going to be hard. I'm just glad you're staying. MASKED MAN Where are you Thomas? MASKED MAN Come on. I want you dead. THOMAS Get out my house! Get the fuck out my house! THOMAS It wasn't me. It wasn't me. THOMAS It wasn't me. MASKED MAN 1 Just say it! SAY IT!! THOMAS It' wasn't me. MASKED MAN 1 Bury him! We pull back, losing sight of them, as they drag him towards his muddy grave, moving into darkness, as we.